Why CPM Should Not Be Banned as a Party ?

From Bartaman-25.05.11

If you found this article interesting, please copy the code below to your website.
x 
Share

13 Responses to “Why CPM Should Not Be Banned as a Party ?”

  1. mrinal 25 May 2011 at 10:55 PM #

    সন্ত্রাস -এর বাতাবরন তইরি-র জন্য সিপিয়াইএম দল-কে banned করা উচিত।

  2. Manasi 26 May 2011 at 11:18 AM #

    Thnks 4 Article

  3. Profile photo of Sumitra Padmanabhan
    sumitra di 26 May 2011 at 12:57 PM #

    Shamindra– this article is by EX High court Judge Bhagabatiprasad Bandopadhyay– please note the weight of his argument.

  4. Madhusudan Mahato 26 May 2011 at 1:19 PM #

    Thanks to Bartaman and SRAI.

  5. Alak Sasmal 26 May 2011 at 1:24 PM #

    CPIM কে অবশ্যই নিষিদ্ধ করা উচিত

  6. Sourav Chakraborty 27 May 2011 at 10:18 PM #

    Disclaimer: I am not a CPI(M) sympathizer or supporter.

    From members of SRAI, I had expected a bit more maturity. Jumping into conclusions based on just a newspaper article is certainly not very rational, particularly when that newspaper is well known to be very anti-CPM. Whatever is printed in a new paper is not absolutely true.

    I don’t deny that it is highly possible that CPM armed cadres had terrorized people of WB for so long. In fact, I believe that it is a fact. However, I doubt that all the weapons recovered were “clean”- I mean not “planted”.

    Lots of weapons were found wrapped in CPM party flag- that is the biggest reason I have such doubts. Would the cadres be so foolish to bury/hide the weapons with their party flag? Although I believe these weapons were actually used by CPM cadres, it is just my belief- not a proved fact. I hope rationalists will approach news papers with a fair bit of skepticism and look for other independent corroborating evidence before believing such controversial news.

  7. Profile photo of Sumitra Padmanabhan
    SUCHETANA 28 May 2011 at 10:10 AM #

    SOURABH — A SIMILAR DEMAND WAS PUBLISHED IN THIS SITE AS WAY BACK AS IN 2009. CPM -POLICE ATROCITIES WERE AT ITS PEAK THEN.I REMEMBER, IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN THOUGHT BY JUKTIBADIS ALONE.
    BUT NOW– AFTER DAILY RECOVERY OF ARMS & UNIFORMS FROM CPM PARTY OFFICES– THE GRAVITY OF THE ARGUMENT IS DEFINITELY MORE — PARTICULARLY WHEN COMING FROM AN EX-H.C. JUDGE

    SO srai HAS DONE A GOOD JOB — MORE PEOPLE CAN READ THE ARTICLE …. AND THINK. NOBODY CAN JUMP INTO CONCLUSION … ONE CAN ONLY THINK WITH CLARITY. THAT’S WHAT COMMON READERS CAN DO. REST WILL BE DONE BY LAW OF THE LAND.

  8. A K Bairagi 28 May 2011 at 9:06 PM #

    সি পি এম কে এখনি নিশিদ্ধ করা উচিত। বাঁচোয়া যে এতদিন বাদে একটি টেররিস্ট পার্টির হাত থেকে আমরা নিষ্কৃতি পেয়েছি।

  9. KAUSIK SARKAR 29 May 2011 at 7:03 AM #

    Thanks to Ms.Suchetana for your clarification from a rational & secular mind.

  10. Dwijapada Bouri 30 May 2011 at 5:00 PM #

    Thanks to Bhagabati Prashd for his Articles

  11. Bidesh 5 June 2011 at 10:29 PM #

    No. 1 : War is an industry and that is why arms are made. If there is no war , the industry will break down.

    No 2 : A gun is made to fight against a gun .

    No 3 : No political party is bad . People are not good.

    No 4 : Neither Buddha Babu or Biman Babu told the CPM supporters to kill villagers in Netai Gram nor Didi asked her people to abuse and slap, cancer affected Eliyas Khan ( can not remember the name properly ), an aged CPM supporter. So people do wrong thing and parties suffer a lot.

    No 5 : As — allll izzz not WEllll : allll izzz not baaad.

    No 6 : And additionally , who goes to ‘LANKA’ , STARTS following ,’RAVAAN’.( Common General Rule )

    No 7 :So banning is not ethical.

    .

  12. Profile photo of Sumitra Padmanabhan
    Sumitra 8 June 2011 at 11:26 AM #

    I partly agree with Bidesh. ‘Banning’ was just a comment — so set people thinking. And you have really thought about it.

    Its very true. All weapons should be banned first. It is the arms manufacturers and arms dealers that are benefiting in the process.

    We would like to have an article from Bidesh on this issue. Please send it to the following mail with your address and full name.

    sumitra_humanist@hotmail.com. It can be either in English or Bangla

    from SUMITRA PADMANABHAN
    HUMANISTS’ ASSOCIATION
    Also editor of this site

  13. dot t 14 August 2011 at 6:58 PM #

    An ex minister of erstwhile Left Front government was arrested on charge of organizing mass killing of opposition workers and burying the dead bodies to hush up evidences. If this charge is proved it will be difficult to believe that such heinous act took place without the complicity of top leadership of CPIM. Then the argument for banning CPIM will be strengthened.


Leave a Reply